Why are expensive hand tools better than cheaper ones?

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

Schurkey

Supporting Member
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2018
Messages
11,281
Reaction score
14,280
Location
The Seasonally Frozen Wastelands
Wtf is a distributor dyno???
No doubt one of the many different models of Sun distributor machines; a unit that spins the distributor with connections to a strobe light to indicate each "spark". There are various gauges--Tach, Dwell, Vacuum (and a vacuum pump for testing the vacuum advance) and an ohmmeter for testing points resistance.

The strobe shows against a degree wheel, you can verify cylinder-to-cylinder spark variation.

The "Hot-rod" usefulness is in verifying the centrifugal and vacuum advance curves as a function of distributor RPM or vacuum level.

They were in use with better shops (and schools) in the '40s, '50s, '60s, and began to die-out in the '70s, even before cars got distributorless ignitions. Electronic ignitions made distributors so "trouble-free" :) that no one bothered to pull them out for testing. My high-school auto mechanics class had a Sun, the Sun I bought came from a Vo-Tech (High school?) in Utah.

I had a very compact Allen distributor machine; sat on a table-top--about the size of a typical stereo receiver, but taller to support a Chevy distributor. Damaged in a garage fire. I bought a full-fledged Sun unit to replace the Allen. The Sun machines are physically larger than my old Allen; and mostly they're parked on a dedicated cabinet that holds various supplies--a magnetic-pickup amplifier for electonic ignitions, fresh sets of points, various distributor tools, an adapter for Flathead Ford distributors, and perhaps a rack of eight spark plugs for verifying the actual sparks made by the distributor (kind of a teaching tool for students, not really useful otherwise.) My Sun is usable, but kinda wounded--the strobe is no longer bright and stable. No doubt the electronics that power the strobe need some lovin'.

Photos of various Sun models, shamelessly stolen from the internet:
You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach
 
Last edited:

SUBURBAN5

I'm Awesome
Joined
Jul 18, 2020
Messages
4,723
Reaction score
8,024
Location
Houston
You put a distributor on, spin it up, and watch its advance curve. Change as desired.
I never knew that lol
No doubt one of the many different models of Sun distributor machines; a unit that spins the distributor with connections to a strobe light to indicate each "spark". There are various gauges--Tach, Dwell, Vacuum (and a vacuum pump for testing the vacuum advance) and an ohmmeter for testing points resistance.

The strobe shows against a degree wheel, you can verify cylinder-to-cylinder spark variation.

The "Hot-rod" usefulness is in verifying the centrifugal and vacuum advance curves as a function of distributor RPM or vacuum level.

They were in use with better shops (and schools) in the '40s, '50s, '60s, and began to die-out in the '70s, even before cars got distributorless ignitions. Electronic ignitions made distributors so "trouble-free" :) that no one bothered to pull them out for testing. My high-school auto mechanics class had a Sun, the Sun I bought came from a Vo-Tech (High school?) in Utah.

I had a very compact Allen distributor machine; sat on a table-top--about the size of a typical stereo receiver, but taller to support a Chevy distributor. Damaged in a garage fire. I bought a full-fledged Sun unit to replace the Allen. The Sun machines are physically larger than my old Allen; and mostly they're parked on a dedicated cabinet that holds various supplies--a magnetic-pickup amplifier for electonic ignitions, fresh sets of points, various distributor tools, an adapter for Flathead Ford distributors, and perhaps a rack of eight spark plugs for verifying the actual sparks made by the distributor (kind of a teaching tool for students, not really useful otherwise.) My Sun is usable, but kinda wounded--the strobe is no longer bright and stable. No doubt the electronics that power the strobe need some lovin'.

Photos of various Sun models, shamelessly stolen from the internet:
You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach


You must be registered for see images attach
Wow that's awesome. I had no idea that existed but it makes sense. I wish I would of learned that in school. Pretty neat how real mechanics use to diagnose parts back then. Once again I learn something new:)
 

SlowZ71

OBS Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
68
Reaction score
59
Location
Northern Utah
I just like using my nice tool truck tools.
Most of my MAC and Snap-On stuff is used, and a good portion of it is from my mechanic buddy; a majority, of not all of my Matco stuff is brand new. I know most stuff from Matco is just rebranded tools, but I can get more stuff cheaper wheeling and dealing with the Matco man.
I'm trying to get myself over wanting a Snappy or MAC toolbox since it'll just be going in my shop; but I still want a quality box. Milwaukee boxes look sweet AF, and the Husky Industrials feel solid for a big box store brand, anyone got any experience with either?
My 2nd tool box was a husky with the roll cab and the top box. Had power to top box, can’t remember about the lower one. Pretty decent box, especially for home garage use where it doesn’t move. Sold it to my buddy I work with and he still has it. The shop I work in now has us moving our boxes out to the shop floor so it gets fairly hard use, but is still holding up well.
 

skylark

I'm Awesome
Joined
Nov 15, 2011
Messages
7,936
Reaction score
8,047
Location
Grants Pass, OR
A few years ago, we cut a 1974 peterbilt cabover in half and streched it to a "Truck Trailer" with a 24 foot bed
Pretty damn involved.
The friggen cornwell guy came buy to sell us his ******** and hooked his truck on the end frame of the pete, knocked it off of the stands.
And tried to square it up by offering us a tool discount.
When that didnt work he wanted us to write a fake estimate for his insurance.
You guys just dont really understand how tough it is when you have a mini mansion and a boat payment and all the kids are in college.
What a gig.
250 grand to get in the door.
Rip off every young mechanic.
Make sure the old mechanics are big fans by sucking out all of their money so they put downward pressure on the younger guys in order to let themsevles feel better about being schmucked by the the guy who owns the mansion
Awesome.
Its all a scam.
Its just Mary Kay Cosmettics for men.
Expensive financed male Tupperware with "free" hats
I can agree with quite a bit of what you've said. I will agree that there is pressure that to be the best, that you have to own the perception of the best.

That being said, sometimes it comes down to you want what you want simply because that is what you want. This is why I have a custom ordered Snap On tool cart on order. It will replace my current Harbor Freight cart. I looked seriously at Harbor Freights newest cart considering that it is almost 1/4 of the cost but there were specific reasons why I didn't.

The first was that I really didn't like the latches on the display model, the upper latches wouldn't hold and one of the middle was broken. I get that this was a display but I move my cart constantly and quality latches are important to me.

Next is that I have a 1/2 flex head digital torque wrench in a plastic case. It wouldn't fit in the newest HF cart. If I took it out of the case it would fit but honestly, it is a precision tool that was dang expensive and I don't want it bouncing around when I move the cart.

Lastly by custom ordering I was able to get the drawer layout exactly how I like it. I ordered two shallow drawers on top so I can have my wrenches in the top and my electrical tools in the one underneath. I also went with black and purple trim because purple is my favorite color and it will look great with the black.

So yeah, I'm spending more but I'm getting exactly what I need and it is customized to what I want.
 

TechNova

I'm Awesome
Joined
Aug 11, 2018
Messages
636
Reaction score
803
Location
Wis
A few years ago, we cut a 1974 peterbilt cabover in half and streched it to a "Truck Trailer" with a 24 foot bed
Pretty damn involved.
The friggen cornwell guy came buy to sell us his ******** and hooked his truck on the end frame of the pete, knocked it off of the stands.
And tried to square it up by offering us a tool discount.
When that didnt work he wanted us to write a fake estimate for his insurance.
You guys just dont really understand how tough it is when you have a mini mansion and a boat payment and all the kids are in college.
What a gig.
250 grand to get in the door.
Rip off every young mechanic.
Make sure the old mechanics are big fans by sucking out all of their money so they put downward pressure on the younger guys in order to let themsevles feel better about being schmucked by the the guy who owns the mansion
Awesome.
Its all a scam.
Its just Mary Kay Cosmettics for men.
Expensive financed male Tupperware with "free" hats
Sounds like you are still holding a grudge about the frame. Tool companies provide a service, people are free to buy what they want, the aren't sheep that follow the leader. Some people are terribly inefficient and don't mind the cheap tools. Reminds me of the Harbor Freight paint gun buyers that say the guns are as good as a SATA or Iwata. First , they me be good at their skill level. Second, do they really think the real painters are that dumb that they pay $800-1200 per gun if they weren't actually much better? Not everything is a conspiracy.
 

Hipster

I'm Awesome
Joined
Mar 7, 2017
Messages
3,553
Reaction score
6,211
Location
Liberty, NC
Our Snap On guys do one heck of a business selling boxes. Part of that is because they know that if they almost cut their throat selling a box that you're more likely to fill it up with their tools. Don't be afraid to work a deal.

I can agree with quite a bit of what you've said. I will agree that there is pressure that to be the best, that you have to own the perception of the best.

That being said, sometimes it comes down to you want what you want simply because that is what you want. This is why I have a custom ordered Snap On tool cart on order. It will replace my current Harbor Freight cart. I looked seriously at Harbor Freights newest cart considering that it is almost 1/4 of the cost but there were specific reasons why I didn't.

Lastly by custom ordering I was able to get the drawer layout exactly how I like it. I ordered two shallow drawers on top so I can have my wrenches in the top and my electrical tools in the one underneath. I also went with black and purple trim because purple is my favorite color and it will look great with the black.

So yeah, I'm spending more but I'm getting exactly what I need and it is customized to what I want.
Same here, but I'm a bodyguy so when I wanted a nice one I custom ordered a box with every deep drawer option I could get in my color choice and trim options. lol Deep box at 32'' and drawers almost 30" front to back. I have 2 2" drawers but everything else is 4" or better. I too like my stuff in the cases. I can fit my stud gun kit in it's case vertically in one of the bottom drawers. I wanted a box I could fit all my bulky stuff in instead of it laying around.

I had waited until the Matco boxes went on sale which there is a short time annually they do it and The Matco guy gave me $2500 trade in on a Snap-on bottom box I used for 10 years that I paid $1000 dollars for. The Snap-on guy was giving me crap about warrantee on one of the wheels and a couple drawer slides. Snap-on wanted $4k for a top box to go on it. Needless to say He didn't get the sale. lol The look on his face when he saw the new box=priceless!
 
Last edited:

someotherguy

Truly Awesome
Joined
Sep 28, 2013
Messages
10,084
Reaction score
14,903
Location
Houston TX
I've said it before probably enough times half of y'all have heard it, I think the only brand new Snap-On tool I've ever bought off the truck was a Pozi-Driv screwdriver. I have a bunch of Snappy stuff including 2 large roll boxes and a top box, didn't pay even 1/4 of truck price for them. Buy used.

Richard
 
Top