@someotherguy
Hey Richard, how does the F450/550 ride compared to the 3500hd? I haven't taken a measurement on anything but I'm considering swapping the entire suspension from the Ford when I go 4wd.
All the 450's and 550's I've driven are not only the shortest wheelbase available (basically 60" cab-to-axle, so whatever Ford's variation of a short 3500HD's 135.5" is) - that's going to ride rough on its own, BUT, they also always have the weight of a wrecker unit out back, which is significant. How much? Not sure, as the manufacturers aren't really big on telling you how much, but trust me, it's a lot! Even so, they're sprung heavily enough to take the weight of the unit and whatever you might load on it. Lift capacity is 4K on most of these units, tow rating 7K-8K depending on model, minimum GVWR suggested for a chassis these units mount to is 14.5K
Also something to consider is we do run the tires at 85-90psi full time, and those comparing a 450 to a 550, a 450 comes with load range F tires (as does your HD), a 550 comes with load range G. I would absolutely expect a difference in ride quality there, too.
These trucks do ride like crap, but it's not really a surprise. Oh, and the overwhelming majority of trucks I've driven are 2WD; we do have two 4WD trucks that were bought only because they were available when new chassis became really scarce, but I haven't operated those trucks yet. All our trucks are gas engine but I've driven diesels at previous jobs, not a big difference in ride, but a little bit extra counterweight via the diesel helps with heavy vehicles on the hook.
Richard