When my GMT400 isn't enough...

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

billy bee

Newbie
Joined
Mar 22, 2015
Messages
17
Reaction score
16
Location
Arroyo Grande, CA
I made the switch to a GMT800 and may be able to add some perspective. The backstory: I have towed race trailers with other GMT400's in the past. I had a 92 K2500454, 4:10, 'burb with a dual rear wheel kit on it. That really towed well. Also had a 94 K3500 ECLB with the 6.5. It towed well, too. Both would haul my 34' enclosed two-car hauler with ease. Both towed all over the the east coast and mid-west. Not many steep or long grades, like in the Rockies, but plenty of hilly towing. including in my home state of Vermont.

In 2010, I bought a 1995 K1500 ECSB, 3:73 gears, for $3500 with 75k. Towed a utility trailer and ski boat with it, no problem. Then started towing race cars...problem. I was towing a 20' enclosed trailer which was right at my tow capacity of the K1500 at 7000#. It was a great truck otherwise. During our ownership, we rebuilt the trans and did the rear end bearings. Otherwise, basic maintenance and minor repairs. Good truck. Just sold it for $3500 with 150k on the clock.

Wanting some additional towing capacity, I bought a 2002 2500HD 4x4 CCSB, 6.0, 4:10 gears, for $7400. There really is no comparison between the trucks. I find the 800 better in almost every way. Yes, the interior materials are really cheap plastic. Yes, it is more complex. Yes, parts are more expensive...but not by much.

The thing that really bothers me has been mentioned: it's a huge adjustment running much higher rpm's in the 800. I drive high-revving cars in wheel-to-wheel racing but am wildly uncomfortable with the way the 6.0 spins up. Somewhere deep inside my reptilian brain, I have a genetic predisposition to torquey V8-powered trucks that don't rev like that. It just feels wrong. It should pull like a freight train up to 3500 rpm and then poop out. This 6.0 comes on cam at 3500 and screams like a banshee from there up to red line. In its defense, it does so without complaining. Trans and engine temp stay cool. It's remarkable. Weird, but remarkable.

Otherwise, it's all upside. It rides much better than my 400. It's quieter...I can actually have a conversation with my wife while driving on the highway (but you may not want that). It is more efficient. I can easily get 16mpg on the highway...never got that in my 400. It has way more power.

I am very happy with the switch. I miss this forum, however. This is by far the best automotive forum I've every been on. I wish there were something half as good for the GMT800. I am on the SilveradoSierra forum, which is good but nowhere near as technical and most people have NBS trucks.

Good luck with your decision. Let us know what you do.

bb
 

Jermaine Smith

I'm Awesome
Joined
Jan 12, 2018
Messages
136
Reaction score
54
Location
Mississippi
I made the switch to a GMT800 and may be able to add some perspective. The backstory: I have towed race trailers with other GMT400's in the past. I had a 92 K2500454, 4:10, 'burb with a dual rear wheel kit on it. That really towed well. Also had a 94 K3500 ECLB with the 6.5. It towed well, too. Both would haul my 34' enclosed two-car hauler with ease. Both towed all over the the east coast and mid-west. Not many steep or long grades, like in the Rockies, but plenty of hilly towing. including in my home state of Vermont.

In 2010, I bought a 1995 K1500 ECSB, 3:73 gears, for $3500 with 75k. Towed a utility trailer and ski boat with it, no problem. Then started towing race cars...problem. I was towing a 20' enclosed trailer which was right at my tow capacity of the K1500 at 7000#. It was a great truck otherwise. During our ownership, we rebuilt the trans and did the rear end bearings. Otherwise, basic maintenance and minor repairs. Good truck. Just sold it for $3500 with 150k on the clock.

Wanting some additional towing capacity, I bought a 2002 2500HD 4x4 CCSB, 6.0, 4:10 gears, for $7400. There really is no comparison between the trucks. I find the 800 better in almost every way. Yes, the interior materials are really cheap plastic. Yes, it is more complex. Yes, parts are more expensive...but not by much.

The thing that really bothers me has been mentioned: it's a huge adjustment running much higher rpm's in the 800. I drive high-revving cars in wheel-to-wheel racing but am wildly uncomfortable with the way the 6.0 spins up. Somewhere deep inside my reptilian brain, I have a genetic predisposition to torquey V8-powered trucks that don't rev like that. It just feels wrong. It should pull like a freight train up to 3500 rpm and then poop out. This 6.0 comes on cam at 3500 and screams like a banshee from there up to red line. In its defense, it does so without complaining. Trans and engine temp stay cool. It's remarkable. Weird, but remarkable.

Otherwise, it's all upside. It rides much better than my 400. It's quieter...I can actually have a conversation with my wife while driving on the highway (but you may not want that). It is more efficient. I can easily get 16mpg on the highway...never got that in my 400. It has way more power.

I am very happy with the switch. I miss this forum, however. This is by far the best automotive forum I've every been on. I wish there were something half as good for the GMT800. I am on the SilveradoSierra forum, which is good but nowhere near as technical and most people have NBS trucks.

Good luck with your decision. Let us know what you do.

bb

I done heard guys that left GMT 400 trucks behind for GMT 800 and went back to GMT 400 trucks. I never owned a NBS truck but i do own a 2000 LS2 powered 6 speed Z28 camaro and a 97 3/4 ton 454 vortec motor truck. Im a LS guy at heart as my car pumping out right at 490 at the rear wheels. I just dont see a 6.0 motor towing better than the Vortec 454 motor in my pickup. Maybe im wrong.....
 

billy bee

Newbie
Joined
Mar 22, 2015
Messages
17
Reaction score
16
Location
Arroyo Grande, CA
I just dont see a 6.0 motor towing better than the Vortec 454 motor in my pickup. Maybe im wrong.....

Comparing the 6.0 to the 454? You're not wrong. Comparing the 6.0 to the 350? It's close. I think I like the GMT800 better for things other than the LS engine. I do like the LS, but it's soooo different than the SBC engines. I'm really gonna miss my GMT400.

bb
 

someotherguy

Truly Awesome
Joined
Sep 28, 2013
Messages
10,037
Reaction score
14,824
Location
Houston TX
I still dreaming of a newer 8.1 Kodiak/Topkick with the firewall back an Express van.
If you can dream it, you can build it...theoretically it shouldn't be that difficult since from 2003-up that's what the Kodiak/Topkick body is anyway, a cutaway Express/Savanna van. Adjust the wheelbase and chop the frame, drop that van body on there and enjoy. Probably need some silly looking fender flares to cover the C&C rear but a little fiberglass work and you're there.

This van caught my eye a while back at the impound lot. It's the 3500HD Vandura so it's got the Dana 80, beam front axle, 10x7.25 bolt pattern 19.5's, etc. just like a 3500HD. Someone made a nice custom airbag setup for the rear axle presumably so it would ride smoother and not destroy the satellite comm gear in the box.

http://3500hd.com/index.php?topic=1213.0

Richard
 
Last edited:

someotherguy

Truly Awesome
Joined
Sep 28, 2013
Messages
10,037
Reaction score
14,824
Location
Houston TX
I done heard guys that left GMT 400 trucks behind for GMT 800 and went back to GMT 400 trucks. I never owned a NBS truck but i do own a 2000 LS2 powered 6 speed Z28 camaro and a 97 3/4 ton 454 vortec motor truck. Im a LS guy at heart as my car pumping out right at 490 at the rear wheels. I just dont see a 6.0 motor towing better than the Vortec 454 motor in my pickup. Maybe im wrong.....
I've owned more GMT400's than I can count including some very labor-intensive builds and several wreckers with Vortec 7.4's (and one with a TBI 7.4) - I love them. As some may recall I ran a GMT400-only salvage yard for a few years, too.

With that said my current DD is a 2006 Silverado SS. It's an awesome truck. Lots of power, fun to drive, all the gadgets, very comfortable, etc. The wife got immediately jealous when I brought it home, so I bought her one to match.

I still miss my black '94 C2500LD...big-time. I'm always cruising the CL ads for that special GMT400 that will tempt me back to that world...whether that means a low-mile rare gem that I could just jump into and enjoy, or some beat to hell project that has good bones and lots of potential. I guess I'll always be a GMT400 lover, which explains why I continue to hang out here although I haven't owned one in years. :/

Richard
 

scottydl

I'm Awesome
Joined
Dec 2, 2018
Messages
155
Reaction score
157
Location
Illinois
Thanks billy bee for your perspective. I like all the chatter in this thread, but real world experiences like yours are a tad more useful than the "hey what I would do is drop *** into your Burb for $XXXX and that would be awesome!" ;) Especially for guys who make engine swaps sound as simple as installing a new light bulb... and more power to 'em for that! But not within my wheelhouse.

My Suburban tows my trailer just fine, in fact I often forget its back there on flat ground. Hills and/or hot summer days are a different story though, it seems like a chore for the truck. I keep coming back to wondering if a Vortec (whether 96-99 Suburban, or sufficiently upgrading my current 454) would really make a notable difference. Or if saving up for an early/mid 2000's diesel crew cab would be a better bet.
 

BNielsen

I'm Awesome
Joined
Sep 6, 2018
Messages
2,663
Reaction score
4,174
Location
North Carolina
My father had a 1999 C3500 that he used to pull our 32' travel trailer, and it would pull it, sometimes he'd have to send it all the way to make some hills but on flat ground it pulled like a dream. But unfortunately we were limited on where we could go with that dually, 9 miles to the gallon. Didn't matter if it was loaded or empty.
If I could've gotten my hands on it I could have made it pull better, but it wasn't my truck to modify.

He coughed up bought an LB7 Duramax a couple months ago, it cost about twice as much as the dually did, but it lugs that camper around like it's nothing.

That being said, I love my Vortec 454, and I plan to make it so that it'll pull anything I hook it up to. I'd like to own a diesel at some point. But when I compare maintenance costs to something even as simple as a 12-Valve 5.9L Cummins, I can do a lot more work on the 454 for a little less.

I'd say upgrade your Suburban little by little until you either are satisfied with the performance, or decide to upgrade trucks entirely.
FYI, look South if you'd want a Vortec 454 powered 'Burb, there's still tons of people down here who are using them.
 

scottydl

I'm Awesome
Joined
Dec 2, 2018
Messages
155
Reaction score
157
Location
Illinois
FYI, look South if you'd want a Vortec 454 powered 'Burb, there's still tons of people down here who are using them.

Yeah I was pretty shocked to see the '99 C2500 Suburban in Phoenix Craigslist (posted earlier in this thread) with 135k miles for $3700. I mean that seemed REALLY low priced. Then I just looked again and it's been lowered to $3200... seller must be motivated or there's an underlying problem somewhere. If I could find that in good condition in the Midwest (to inspect in person first) I'd buy it tomorrow.
 
Top