Here's the dope. Went to the local parts store and rented a puller / installer kit and bought feeler gauges and dye. The instructions in the kit were wrong about which threaded insert fit my compressor, but none the less, I was able to correctly space the compressor clutch gap. The clutch is no longer spinning with the pulley when the AC is off.
I had 1/4 of a r134 can, so I splashed some dye on my recharge tool and turned the AC on full blast. Emptied the entire 1/4 can. Clutch never kicked on, I'm suspecting the compressor is either cooked or the 1/4 can wasn't enough to make it kick on. I do have a full can of r134 that I can try tomorrow, however is there a test way to force the clutch on without utilizing my 11$ can of r134? I've seen some people jump the wiring for the low pressure switch, but I don't remember if that forces the compressor on or off.