The closed-cell is somewhat stiffer than the other stuff. It won't roll over as easy. Sooo...
I'd cut the foam on the roof side flat to the way that the console fits to the roof. That'll leave a fairly sharp corner on the foam.
Then soften that edge with the sandpaper so that corner is nice & round.
For where the plastic center goes, (the inner? the insert?) cut the foam so there's about a 3/8" extra & then drop the that center into the console. Doesn't have to be attached with the screws.
Hold it in place firmly & with a new blade in a razor knife, cut the foam following around the outer edge of the inner insert.
Don't saw the blade back-n-forth, up-n-down. That leaves jagged edges.
Try to do one length in one steady cut. That's why the new blade.
Once the vinyl/leather is wrapped that edge will have a nice square transition where it meets that inner insert plastic panel center part piece. Whatever it's called.
My '98's H/L & console. Done with the closed-cell & perforated vinyl.
I added a piece of piping around the perimeter just as an accent. Same piping as the seats. Most never notice.
It was a PitA to do, getting it to lay right.
IIRC, I still wasn't happy with it & after this pic I redid it over. Again.
Scuse the crud pic. Dirty lens.
...& the ugly visors. Has Escalade ones now. Just not done with the perf'd vinyl yet.
You must be registered for see images attach