Greetings Nick88,
Glad to hear that you are making progress by replacing the O2 sensor. I was getting ready to reply that the
only time I've personally had any luck with troubleshooting an O2 sensor with a DC voltmeter reading was when
the heater circuit was open, either sensor or wiring. (And you aren't running a heated O2 -- at least stock.)
But when it came to the actual signal, if the O2 wasn't bad enough to throw a code I normally couldn't come up
with a good answer via the voltmeter alone on the sensor's output signal? For what it's worth, here's an
actual example of a O2 waveform in action on a TBI vehicle:
You must be registered for see images attach
(credit: google search for TBI O2 waveform)
Schurkey and others will refer to the crossing counts to help determine how good/how lazy your sensor is.
Crossing counts is normally defined as how many times the signal crosses over the 0.5v (14.7:1 stoich) level
per second. The faster the better, but it typically varies from ~1 at idle to 5+ times per second on the highway.
And since you don't have a heated O2 sensor, while sitting at a long stop light the sensor may cool off enough
that your engine reverts back to 'Open Loop' operation until you get going again.
As mentioned previously by the talent, the quickest/easiest way to troubleshoot all this is by having
the computer tell you what it's perception of reality is by looking at the
live data. Of course this means
having something capable of this in your hands in 2024 that can graph data from a '88 vintage computer.
(I don't know what the definitive list of advanced functionality scanners that can do this is, but I'm sure that it's a short one.)
I went through your list of repair parts in this thread, but did
not see any mention of the following?
Ignition:
* spark plugs
* spark plug wires
* cap, rotor, coil
Also, especially when low rpm stumble is mentioned:
* EGR valve?
* Knock Sensor?
I'm not advocating for the parts cannon, but especially after your gas mileage dropped down to
5 mpg, it's possible that your spark plugs are all carboned up, making misfiring/misbehaving under
low rpm load much more possible to stimulate?
If you were pull a plug and check the color this would be helpful. And if they have a bunch of miles on
them then consider using this episode as an excuse to replace them all with some fresh ones. (No need
to spend a lot of money, they are easy to get to and you're running a .035" gap.) NOTE: If you do
change them out, then take a group photo, organized exactly as they come out of the engine, and this
way we could look for trends. (ie: spark plugs/cylinders fed by left injector pretty, but plugs fed by right
injector very dark/rich, etc.) FWIW, I've attached an example of what I pulled out of my chore truck so
you can see what I'm looking for.
Of course if your truck is already on the mend then you don't need to pull the plugs for me. Your call. But
if the low rpm misbehavior persists then we do need to give the plugs a look for some old-school troubleshooting
hints.
****
Even though you currently don't have a OBD1 scanner capable of graphing live data, you do have en embedded
diagnostic function in your TBI computer that, with a little practice on your part, will allow you to see the air/fuel
ratio that the
computer has figured out (right or wrong) based upon the signals it's getting from your O2 sensor.
If you already know how to retrieve the TBI's check engine light codes (paper clip on the 2 pins in the ALDL connector)
during KOEO (Key On Engine Off) then you already know how to get into Field Service mode. Just leave the 2
pins jumpered, start the engine, and as soon as the O2 sensor warms up you will see the fast Open Loop flashing
switch to the slower Closed Loop mode. See the attachment from the FSM where they describe this diagnostic
feature. After reading that, if this piques your curiosity, then follow this link where another member of the forum
actually shared a video of what he was seeing: (
TBI SES light in Field Service Mode, unhappy engine demo)
And if you watched the video and the light flashing looks to be semi-random, in actuality there was valid data
being shown. Over here is what I interpreted from that video after reading the FSM description: (
graph of Open Loop
vs Closed Loop vs Duty Cycle)
Being perfectly honest, once you get your ride back to the old (good) gas mileage I'd like to see if your vehicle reverts
to the 50/50 duty cycle. (translated: I don't own a TBI truck, but I'd really like to verify the Field Service mode
functionality for similar troubleshooting sessions w/others.)
Anything you could share on what you are seeing would be appreciated. The more hands-on data like this the
stronger the troubleshooting base that we are all working from. (!)
****
To recap, your engine going from good to bad suddenly could definitely be explained by an O2 sensor going
bad. It will be interesting to see what happens from here. As for the stumble under low rpm load, this may
be a temporary hangover from the plugs getting carboned up during the recent too-rich operation. If the
plugs are newish, then maybe an old-school Italian tuneup will clear the fault? Or if the plugs were ready to
be changed anyway, possibly use this an excuse for a fresh set of plugs...and take a photo of the old ones
and post them here? And if you wish to pursue an answer as to whether or not your computer + new O2
sensor is getting the Closed Loop A/F ratios right, then possibly drive around with the ALDL pins jumpered?
Let us know what you discover. Real world results are a big help in upping our game at this remote
troubleshooting thing over time.
Best of luck.
PS - Part of the reason why I jumped in was that for about a year I owned an '88 K5 Blazer with a 350/granny
4-speed, and I miss it mightily. Anything I can do to help keep one of those on the road feels right. :0)