For metal to metal connections like battery terminals, chassis grounds, starter connections, and the like, this is what you want. Electrically conductive grease designed for the purpose, not dielectric! One tub will last most people the term of their natural lives.
I can't imagine a carbon-laden paste has very low resistance. Yes, it might be "conductive", meaning it might provide a electrical path of a sort, but the resistance I would expect be on the order of 100-1000ohms or greater and, if so, that wouldn't help much in a automotive environment where the currents are typically in the range of 1-100amps.
Indeed, the product mentioned above "prevents static buildup"... which is a very high-voltage scenario in which a "conductive" paste with even 1megaohm path resistance would fill the requirement.
My $0.02
Smear some of that carbon grease on a piece of glass and stick the probes from an ohmmeter into it. Take a picture and report-back on what you've found.
It does reportedly "repels moisture, inhibits corrosion", which is good in an automotive application. They claim "Resistivity of 23Ω.cm"... not sure what that means because: Resistance is linearly proportional to the path length (OK, they mentioned "cm") and inversely proportional to the cross-sectional area (they mentioned nothing of this). Hmm.
It seems the purpose for using
dielectric grease is to protect the connection from corrosion, and do so over a long period of time... I quote: "Permatex
dielectric tune-up
grease protects electrical connections and wiring from salt, dirt and corrosion."
Net-net IMHO (I've been wrong before so today won't be my first):
- either will suffice in the automotive application
- don't believe the carbon stuff will function any better