I also like a plug bc i put a magnetized one in there which i feel helps remove metallic particles plus allows me to monitor things. i use permatex black ultra on gasket surfaces such as oil pans, drain plugs, water pumps, etc and have never had anything leak. I used a fumoto valve for the first time on our new challenger and realized up front i was giving up a magnet and making the drain hole a bit smaller, but i really like that too and would do it again. I got the one with a bib to attach a clear hose for draining, changing that oil is a snap especially with the oil filter in top of engine bay.