One is all that’s NEEDED but both is helpful. No reason not to take them both off. Yep there’s a tiny rubber gasket on the bottom of the washer. They’re supposed to come with your valve cover gasket kit.This is a silly question but there is no reason I can’t take both valve covers off right? I’m pretty sure both sides are leaking oil. Also I believe my valve covers are leaking oil at the bolts on top. Do the bolts need a gasket of some sort or a new washer?