Here is the thing. Whether you are running a clutch fan, a flex fan, an electric fan, or whatever, when you change your OE set up, you change air flow, and CFMs. It is critical, to use a shroud with whatever set up, you use. A shroud will direct air flow, through the whole radiator. Without a shroud, you are not getting air flow over the whole radiator. The advantage of a properly set up electric fans, and shroud, is that at idle, it will pull more air across the radiator than any mechanical fan set up. Also, it eliminates the drag on an engine at high RPMs. It takes some power, to turn any mechanical fan, and the higher the RPMs the more of a drain it takes to turn any mechanical fan. Although this may be only a few HP, it is still a drain on the total HP, the engine makes. Yes, any electric fans set up, will need to be supplied by a large amp alternator, and most likely at least the big 3 upgrade. If by change, someone installed an electric fan set up, and has had issues with this set up, then the set up, was not correct for there application. It really is as simple as that. What ever fan set up, is used, be it electric, or mechanical, the set up that pulls the most CFMs in a proper fan shroud the covers the whole radiator will be the set up, that cools the best. It's is simple math. More air movement, directed across the whole radiator, will be the more effective system. This applies to the whole RPM range. Again, it's this simple. More air flow, properly directed, will cool better then less air flow.