if you're running on just headunit power, i would recommend something with a higher sensitivity. i.e
https://www.parts-express.com/goldwood-gw-s650-4-6-1-2-poly-cone-woofer-4-ohm--290-308
twice the price ($20 vs $10) per speaker but you should have better results in overall sound and loudness
now whether or not it would be a perfect fitment replacement, that's hard to say. i doubt either speaker was designed around car audio use utilizing stock mounting locations. you might get lucky, though. i'd measure the overall outer diameter and baffle cutout diameter of your door panel to make sure. unless you're fine with customizing stuff. shouldnt be too difficult if needing to go that route.
generally i would recommend installing car audio branded coaxial speakers. if you have very little money then swapping the mids with a budget option should work fine. but like i said before you may have to cut something or make a bracket to ensure good fitment