Yeah something is wrong to only be able to get 200 per tank, this is also where people that have deleted their EGR valve start to suffer, I have seen multiple people get rid of their EGR valve on these TBI motor's and loose about 2 mpg out on the highway.
When I bought my truck all it had was LT's and some stupid exhaust setup and I could get 17 all interstate avg. 70 MPH with 3.73's and 265/75/16 with a passenger. I wish I could still run EGR now though.