The Wrong Way...and then the Right Way to Pre-load the Tapered Roller Wheel Bearings in your Full Floater (A cautionary tale)
(Note: The target audience for the following would be someone new to GMT400-era repair, and grew up never having to set up front or rear bearings like this before.)
****
Alright, I've got a couple of agendas I want to service here.
#1) Before doing any repair work on your truck,
first read through the applicable section of
the GM Service Manual for comprehension. And if the hand-drawn illustrations don't give
you everything you need (guilty) ...then go right ahead and watch one or more YouTube
videos for a demo.
#2)
Trust but Verify. And IF the supremely confident youtuber mechanic is telling you the
same story that the GM
Service Manual does, then you should be good to go. But IF their story deviates from the manual, and especially if
they don't make specific mention why they deviated, then Caution! Caution!
(remembering Bitchin' Betty :0)
****
So I'm going to lay out the rest of this 'How To' in the following sequence.
*
The Wrong Way first -- just so we all know what to watch out for.
* The Right Way per the bearing manufacturer. (Timken)
* The Right Way per the GM Service Manual. (And take note how these 2 will match.)
Without further ado, here's the 1st YouTube video.
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Ask yourself, how many ft/lbs of torque did he finally end up with?
And ask yourself, where *exactly* where does all this torque (multiplied by
the mechanical advantage that the thread pitch provides) end up being
concentrated?
That was the very 1st video I found. And I was scratching my head, for
this didn't seem to jibe with what the service manual was describing?
So I went looking for a 2nd video. And this guy seemed
very confident
that he was sharing the good stuff with the viewer:
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
Yikes! Another 'If some is good, Then more is gooder' dude. According
to the Timken video AND the GM Service Manual below, this guy is
extra-confidently sharing
bad guidance.
****
In order to better understand what those 2 previous videos were doing, I
want to show you *exactly* where a lot of that pressure is being concentrated:
Vehicle Wt + load is on face of tapered rollors to race. Excess preload only adds to this workload, and will be enough to squeeze
the lubricating film out & cause the roller/race interface to run dry > overheat > fail. (Watch Timken video below.)
In addition, excess force will also be concentrated where scribe is pointing.
You must be registered for see images attach
Note: This is one of the used Timken bearings I found in the chore truck. They looked as new & spun smooooth, so back in they went.
Now, maybe someone like
@GoToGuy can do the math & figure out what 35+ ft/lbs x the thread pitch
will give us for clamping force...and then further figure out how many square inches of roller face + roller shoulder
contact points are available to spread all that clamping force out on?
But I'm telling you, if you spend a few moments at this web page...if you are
like me the hair on the back of your neck will be standing up. (
Clamp Force calculator)
In English, the PSI loadings between the individual roller contact points & the bearing race from setting the preload to 35+
ft/lbs are way too high! And here's a screen snap from the Timken video below that shows you what you will end up with:
You must be registered for see images attach
And judging from all the viewer comments under those first 2 videos, folks are confused
because of all the conflicting info they are seeing.
****
OK, after the first 2 erroneous videos I finally found some good stuff. As a matter of fact,
since my chore truck came with bearings made by Timken, I wanted to see if maybe the company
that made my bearings had any guidance that also happened to
agree with GM's Service Manual?
Now *THIS* is the video I
really wanted to share. Hopefully you can better appreciate it after what
the 2 well-meaning but inaccurate dudes above told us:
xc_hide_links_from_guests_guests_error_hide_media
OK, for the punchline, here's what the '99 GM C/K Service Manual has for guidance:
NOTE: This procedure is actually under the "11 Inch Ring Gear" section. The "10 1/2 Inch Ring Gear" section
is similar, gives you the same result, but omits the ' .001" to .010" ' final cross-check? Instead of wondering why,
I'll leave this as an exercise for the reader to follow up & sort out for themselves to their satisfaction.
You must be registered for see images attach
So there you have it. Apologies for the length -- I realize a purely cookbook-style answer
takes a lot less reading/typing...but what I'm trying to achieve here is for the newer mechanic
coming up to speed to be able to reason through the process...so that if/when they
encounter mechanical guidance that's potentially destructive, they'll know that right away
thanks to having used the RTFM (Read That Fine Manual) method.
I watch as many youtube videos as anyone, but watching them
after reading through the
Service Manual procedures makes for a better use of my prep time. Especially when dealing
with the precision stuff like adjusting these tapered roller bearings for a long service life.
Safe Travels via setting up your Tapered Roller Bearings for Success --
And as always, thanks for stopping in and checking in on how the Chore Truck is coming along. :0)