Use a known-good (trustworthy, accurate, repeatable) voltmeter...
So ...this is kind of an old thread, but your specifics appealed to me. I recently 'resurrected' my 93, and part of that process was adding the dual 16(?) inch fan/shroud combo from a 2005ish half ton. I've seen them hit 50A+ on startup, and then settle down to 22A-25A...each.
My issue is a little strange. It seems as though my alternator runs out of wind as it heats up, or ...something. And it does heat up. Like, pronto. It gets blister you hot, sometimes faster than the headers.
I bought a USB charger that replaces the cigarette lighter, and it has an LED voltage readout that I've verified to be correct. I use that for my 'inside' measurements. For under hood measurements, an old Wavetek multimeter I've had since before this truck was new. I've added an 8ga direct from the charge post to the B+. And this is a CS144 - supposedly the 130A version. Adding a ground from alt case to B- didn't seem to have any impact at all. Battery and Alt differential is .1v or less both + and -. Voltage drop to the fuse panel (lights and AC on) was interesting. Most places I see -.5v. That's gauges, turn/bu, PCM/IGN, Inj, 4WD, and brake. Third column was weird. HTR-A/C showed -.74, courtesy and parking lights were showing -.9v, and the panel lamps measured -1.8v, and stop being -.3. I suppose the gauge cluster connector is ...crappy?
Before I added the 8ga, I would see maybe 13.2(inside) on startup. Left to idle, it would eventually drop down to 12.4ish. Take off driving, it would go up to 12.8 and remain fairly stable there, even with accessories, lights, blower on high. However, pull into a drive through and idle, it would drop to 12 or even 11.8, and seems like it would drop more the longer I sat there. Turn off the blower and drop the headlights, it's back up around 12.2. Fast idle would bring it back up to 12.8.
Since the 8ga addon, I see 14.4 at the alternator charging lug and 14.2 inside, but only on a cold start. It eventually settles down to about 13.5 at the lug and 13.2 inside - without turning anything on. Take off driving, and it will stay about 13.4. Kick on the lights...down to 12.4 cruise, 11.9 idle. Add the A/C...12.2 cruise, 11.2 idle. Pull into my drive, leave lights and AC on, pop the hood and I have 12.3ish at the charging lug. Also at the lug, fast idle will bring it up to 13.2 or so. That's grounded to the alternator case.
At idle, I put my snap-gauge on the charge wire that disappears into the harness (where does that go, exactly?). It's showing about 55 amps outbound. When I check the 8ga to the B+, I see 14ish amps headed that way at idle, and revving up I saw it as high as 50 amps. When I check the cabling from B+ to the starter, and its secondary that runs the distribution block, I see close to 38 amps outbound. So as near as I can tell, my demand is around 93A at idle with A/C max and lights... hot... no wipers, window motors, stereo, etc. I'm guessing the 14A I see from charging lug to the B+ is part of the 38 amps I see leaving the battery. Would I be correct in thinking the alt at idle is producing about 69A, and the battery is providing the rest of the 93?
I've suspected the alternator for a few weeks now, and this is where I've been leaning:
https://www.mechman.com/alternators/buick/lesabre/3-8l/1986-1991/250-amp-fits-6-12-cs144-cast-case/ No small drop in the bucket for just an alternator, but that's 200A at idle, fits my brackets, and should have headroom for a few stereo amps.
But seeing .2v difference inside to out when voltage is up, and as much as 1.2v difference when voltage is low, makes me wonder what the hell is going on. Am I about to throw money away with a new alternator? I'm really pretty confused.
Hep meh!